Feedback

Editor explains why The Baltimore Sun is ‘no longer a newspaper company’

  • Story Link
  • 18

Categories

img_2905-montyjaypeg
By FERN SHEN
“It’s not in decline,” Baltimore Sun editor Monty Cook said, of his news organization, in a speech yesterday at Johns Hopkins University. “It’s in transition.”

The two-hour talk was a primer for those interested in figuring out where Baltimore’s hometown daily is heading under Cook, who took over in January:

Prepare for blogs, blogs and more blogs, plus Twittering. Learn about “the platform-neutral” newsroom and check out The Guardian, which has one. Read “The Long Tail,” by Chris Anderson and look for more mobile content. “This is the future,” Cook said, brandishing his BlackBerry.

And how about “stories,” especially longer ones produced after weeks or days of reporting? Ehhh, not so much….

“The days of the six-part series are gone,” Cook said, arguing that there are other vehicles for good journalism. “Watergate was beat reporting.”

((Audio from Hopkins))
Memo from Cook announcing newsroom reorganization today.

These were among the takeaway messages Cook conveyed to the audience of about 30 people, a group whose composition captured poignantly the critical juncture reached in the narrative of local journalism, here in Baltimore and across the country:

There were former staff writers for The Washington Post and The Sun, now working in academic public affairs or publishing their own news sites. There were young students asking questions about the availability of jobs with benefits in journalism.

And there, sitting silently, was the Abell Foundation’s Robert Embry, one of the key behind-the-scenes players in an effort to purchase the Sun from its bankrupt owner, Sam Zell’s Tribune Media.

Adding to the oddness of moment was the fact that Embry is almost as famous in town for being un-webby as he is for caring passionately about Baltimore and Baltimore journalism. (He’ll tell you himself that he doesn’t really read email on the computer and has an assistant print out all his messages on paper.)

The trend story reporters hate to write
What drew them together was a talk by Cook organized by Hopkins’ Institute for Policy Studies entitled “Content and News: Protecting What Matters Most.”

Cook began by retelling the story of the collapsing newspaper industry, running down the list of dead or dying papers including local ones, finishing with The New York Times’ latest cutback: the plan to kill off a couple more special sections.

Likening the tectonic changes wrought by the Internet today to those produced by the development of the printing press in the 1400s, he said “when classic monopolies meet disruptive technologies, it’s not pretty.” (He noted that movable type inventor Gutenberg himself died essentially bankrupt.)

The not-so-pretty part in Baltimore is the Sun’s shrinking size and staff, its huge page-one photos and shmooshed-together inside content, its closed foreign and suburban bureaus and its plummeting print circulation and revenue.

The Sun’s daily circulation numbers released in November (218,923 for the six months ending in Sept. 2008, compared to 232,749 for the same period in 2007) represented a six percent year-to-year drop. Sunday circulation fell 3.9 percent during that period, to 350,640.

Cook declined to talk about profits (“we are a private company”) but was enthusiastic about the good news, which is over on the web side. Web traffic for the Sun is up (from 2.5 million unique visitors per month in 2007 to 3.4 million in 2008). The monthly page-view total is “approaching 40 million,” he said.

Morphing Media
While declining to say whether the Sun will euthanize the print version soon, as is rumored, Cook did confirm unequivocally that its days of ascendancy at Calvert Street are over.

Explaining how the organization will re-tool itself for the future he said: “we stop being a newspaper company. Right now. The end.”

So what are they? The Sun will soon be shifting to a “platform-neutral newsroom,” he said. That’s a New Media concept and it means fully integrating the news and online operations – thinking of the web, mobile and other non-print platforms not as an afterthought but as equally-important vehicles for the delivery of content.

“We’ll think of content first,” he said, “and platform second.”

Wake up and smell the platform-neutrality
What that will mean in practice, for Sun readers and reporters, remains to be seen, though Cook gave some clues yesterday. The paper is moving away, for instance, from the practice of withholding prime content for the printed paper. “If a story is ready at 9:30…we are not going to sit on that,” he said.

Reporters will continue to be encouraged to blog and use social networks (Facebook, Twitter, etc.), he said, praising writer-bloggers such as restaurant critic Elizabeth Large, Gus Sentementes, nightlife reporter Sam Sessa and schools reporter Sara Neufeld for cultivating loyal readers who interact with them frequently.

“We want reporters to think of themselves as a brand,” he said, noting that Neufeld assembles gatherings of readers in Tweet-ups to give her feedback.

The restructured Sun also will be encouraging reporters to allow more of themselves in their work, he said.

“The journalists of the past were required to be professional and dispassionate,” he said. “Today’s journalists are required to be professional and passionate,” he said, adding “that does not mean advocacy or bias.”

Still shrinking
So, how many reporters does it take to staff the platform-neutral newsroom (or platform-agnostic, as some call it)? Fewer than are there now, he said, declining to announce specifics on the next round of personnel reductions, rumored to be coming at the Sun for weeks.

“We’ll be smaller at the end of this transition,” he said.

But even with more trimming of the payroll, is there enough income these days to support this re-structured journalism in Baltimore? That was the subject of the very first question at Q & A time: “is online advertising enough?”

Cook’s shoulder-shrugging answer was pretty much all anyone in the business can offer right now:

“Everyone’s searching for the next business model,” he said. “We’re exploring niche products.”

Here he cited Chris Anderson’s book, “The Long Tail,” about why successful businesses in the future will deliver small volumes of tough-to-find stuff to many customers. His main example of the kind of niche product they have attempted so far? The Sun’s free youth-oriented tabloid “b.” He said “b” has 125,000 readers. (Which must just mean, that’s the number that disappear from the honor boxes?)

Good Evening Mr. & Mrs. Dundalk
What else will change? There will be shorter stories, stories turned around more quickly, stories “not done in typical pyramid style,” Cook said. “Quick-hit information as well as in-depth information.” There might even, he speculated, be a return to a style of short-blurb columns seen “in newspapers in the 40s and 50s.” (A Herb Caen or Walter Winchell reference?)

Content-sharing with other media (the Sun has made such deals with WJZ-TV and The Washington Post) is another useful strategy, he said, as is aggregating from local specialty news sites and blogs. Don’t you worry, he was asked, about the quality of that information?

“Some blogs are screeds. But there are a lot of very important blogs out there,” he said. “It’s a bit of a Wild West situation,” he said, comparing the media landscape today to that of America in the 1700s and 1800s, when people could choose from a plethora of papers, each with its own explicit point of political point of view.

(Cook didn’t mention it yesterday, but the Sun is trying to tame the west a bit, with legal action against a blogger. The paper recently sent a cease-and-desist letter to Inside Charm City’s Jeff Quinton, saying he was taking too much copy and simply reprinting it, according to a story on Wired magazine’s website.)

Cook praised the Sun’s successful enterprise projects from the past year – coverage of the indictment of Mayor Sheila Dixon, the ground rent series, the profile of Baltimore Schools Superintendent Andres Alonso – and said the organization remains committed to local enterprise reporting. But he acknowledged that the need to narrow the paper’s focus is frustrating.

“Would I love to be able to produce the 1995 newspaper?” he said. “It would be my pleasure.”

Still Cook seems to relish the challenge of playing the hand he’s been dealt, judging by the newspaper movie he was touting to young grad students: the 1952 Humphrey Bogart film, “Deadline U.S.A.” The basic story? A crusading Bogey battles to get out a story about a violent mobster and he’s only got three days to do it: the paper is about to be sold.

BONUS FOR HANGING IN FOR 1,406 words:
Brew media blogger Joan Jacobson recalls what it was like when Baltimore’s public officials had nosy journalists from three different newspapers falling all over themselves to find malfeasance and hold government accountable.

Baltimore Brew is a moderated site that encourages the free and open exchange of ideas in a climate of mutual respect. We reserve the right - but do not assume any obligation - to delete or withhold the publication of comments that violate our standards. Comments that are obscene, libelous or defamatory, or include vicious personal attacks will not be published. Racist remarks, sexist remarks, disgusting stuff, blatant commercial self-promotion – you get the idea – if it crosses our line, we’re not going to run it.

  • Grant Corley

    The Sun was a daily must-read until about four years ago. At that point it became a paper that warranted flipping through each morning before purchasing to make sure you weren’t buying a lemon. Sadly, as of last August, it’s not even worth kicking the tires.

    The website is worth spending about 20 seconds on each day, with its surprisingly short articles, canned content, and lack of local news. Maybe that’s all the management wants or expects anymore, but it’s not helping any of us be informed as citizens.

    Other than the weekly City Paper, a few blogs and a handful of good radio interview programs around the dial, Baltimoreans are being starved of basic, substantive local news coverage.

    I hope against all odds that The Sun is able to figure out a way to generate enough money to begin substantial reporting again in the future, whether that’s on the web or in some other media.

    In the meantime, the city chugs along on with no daily news coverage. And I suspect most people don’t care anymore. The newspapers truly are dying like huge moths.

  • Linda Wheeler

    Well done story, or should I say, blog.
    Sign me up.
    Linda Wheeler

    • Editor

      Thanks, Linda! Hope all’s well with you. We’re trying not to get too hung up on terminology and just focusing on getting people to read us. We’re glad you did….

  • Wilson Breen

    Mr. Cook presided over two redesigns of the Sun. In each case he made the paper progressively worse switching gimmicky design tactics with what was once real journalistic content. Cook and his handlers at Tribune presume that readers don’t really notice when the “little things” disappear from the paper and are somehow wowed by 10 or more shades of amber on a page. In other words, he thinks readers are stupid.
    I think there is an opening in Baltimore for a brave, new company willing to take a risk and produce a journalistic product readers can once again trust. Maybe it’s the Abell Foundation. If they buy the Sun, they’d be well advised to give Cook a pink slip and start fresh. There’s a lot of talent that would love to return and start doing honest, meaningful journalism once again without compromising the integrity of the product and those who produce it.

  • John Griffith

    Not to harp on terminology but “platform-agnostic”? Stick to platform-neutral. Agnosticism is not a synonym for neutrality.

    Best of luck to The Sun!

  • Tom

    Mr. Breen,
    You seem to have your timeline backwards. All of these changes didn’t cause the current state of the newspaper. It was a reaction to it. Prior to the cuts and redesigns the paper was fully staffed and doing “meaningful journalism” as recent as 4 years ago as the first poster mentioned yet circulation and revenue were nosediving at an alarming rate. No one at the Sun would ever actually want to replace front page journalism with pictures, cut sections, shrink the physical size, and sell A1 ads. But, if you don’t have enough money to pay your mortgage you either need to go buy a smaller house or get foreclosed. The Sun decided it would be best to get a smaller house.

  • Mary Lou White

    As someone who spent most of my life at a newspaper, it’s painful to have to watch the scrabbling to find a way to survive.
    I hope that the Sun and other papers find it.

  • Jeff Price

    Monty Cook is an imbecile, but he’s right about one thing: The Baltimore Sun is not a newspaper company anymore.

  • Jeff Price

    moderation? ok he’s a fool

  • Debbie Jones

    I miss the The Sun. I miss reading it. I miss the sense of security that came with knowing that an organization with some clout was paying attention to corrupt politicians, shady business people, polluters and other unscrupulous Marylanders.

    Until the last few years, I didn’t leave the house in the morning without reading the paper cover-to-cover. Now, the paper sits for days before I pick it up, and when I do, it takes less than five minutes to read.

    Although I have continued to subscribe on principle, it’s such a waste of time and money that I question myself every time I open the paper.

  • Wrong Assumption

    There are some errors in Tom’s comments. There was some dip before the first redesign, but it mostly started after. There was a leveling off in circulation and a bit of stability before the second redesign (or fourth, depending on how you look at it) last year.

  • http://ConsumerWingman.blogspot.com Dan Thanh

    I hope that Monty finds a way to make it work so that The Sun will thrive again. As much as I applaud him and the staff for doing everything they can to keep up with the fast pace of changing technology, I can’t help but believe in my heart that people want news. Perhaps they don’t want a long six-day series, but they want real news about what’s going on in politics, neighborhoods, business, etc.

    Without real, reported stories (I’ll take mine without the passion, please, just hard core facts because all that passion skirts dangerously close to bias to me) that reporters spend time digging up, then where is the news in newspaper or news media if we’re talking different platforms?

    Keep cutting resources, keep cutting staff and you won’t have the manpower or ability to dig for those stories anymore. That’s what I fear this new age of journalism is leading us. As someone who still blogs, I depend on newspapers a great deal to tell me what’s going on (beyond blog chatter and screeds and the lively personalities offered in blogs) in the world around me.

    Finally, beyond that, I miss the ability of reporters to tell stories about real people, real trends and the oddities and flavor of Maryland in the creative, sometimes poetic, but almost always great writing you used to find every day in the paper. And it’s not because the reporters there aren’t capable of that type of writing anymore, it’s because the “platform” they work for doesn’t really allow for that kind of writing anymore.

    I hope every day that The Sun and other papers around the country find a way to make money off all this new technology, but also preserve what is so great about newspapers: being an important watchdog for the community while also offering up great storytelling every day.

    Best to all still fighting the good fight.

  • usha nellore

    Cook is enacting a horrible farce.
    The Sun needs to change hands and do it fast!
    The paper has no substance, it’s not even fluff,
    To witness its decimation is getting tough.

    Cook is serving us tweets and bleeps,
    Thinks we’ll follow him like idiot sheep,
    If I want a brand I’ll go looking for shoes,
    Cut the crap out and give me the truth.

    I don’t need Cook to aggregate for me,
    Or indulge in glorious pyramidal schemes,
    Or turn out reports like eggs over easy,
    Put seismic events in blurbs that are measly.

    I see the platform–a wooden dais,
    Cook in the center smugly seated,
    Claiming there is no “bull or bias”
    In his borrowed stories oft repeated,

    On either side of him the tweet-ups rage,
    The entire world gathers and chatters,
    The babble is loud and incoherent,
    And this to Cook is news that matters!

    Zell hides in his dell and pulls the puppets,
    He casts the crumbs and asks for crumpets,
    Cook’s job is to create a popular product,
    With no ingredients in his pockets.

    Subscribe to the SUN? What for my friends?
    Each AM to read what the twits have twittered?
    And experience the void of a shallow page,
    Handed by Cook in a transition phase,

    I’ll take a bow with this piece of wisdom,
    Twittered by the bard straight into my brain,
    We are merely players including Cook,
    And all the world– a great big stage.

    Usha Nellore

  • http://citythatbreeds.com Evan

    I don’t know how i missed this article previously but it’s really good stuff. I had no idea Inside Charm City was threatened with legal action – and being a small-time Baltimore blogger myself it’s a good lesson in tempering one’s own tendency to “parasitize the host.” K

    Keep up the good work yall

    • Editor

      thanks, Evan, best of luck to you on your site and thanks for the Brew and Baltimorphosis links, btw!

  • http://google.com/335 sandra742

    Hi! I was surfing and found your blog post… nice! I love your blog. :) Cheers! Sandra. R.

  • Lynn Miller

    My husband went to school with Jeff Price and would like to get in touch with him. Do you have an email address for him.

    Thanks

  • http://www.jewishtimes.com/index.php/jewishtimes/opinion/jt/comment/normal_chaos/ abe

    http://www.jewishtimes.com/index.php/jewishtimes/opinion/jt/comment/normal_chaos/

    I must say I have to agree with the others who skim The Sun in the morning, like one of those instant breakfasts, and then wonder why I’m still hungry. I opined on the broader subject and have included a link above.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

    • Yesterday, when Baltimore web developer and Ignite Baltimore co-founder Mike Subelsky tweeted that he was about to witness Nik Wallenda’s tightrope walk across the Inner Harbor, my ears perked up. Pix to come, Subelsky promised. Oooh, send them along I said! Recognizing his citizen journalist moment, Subelsky kindly agreed and sent along some great photos. [...]

Twitter

Facebook