Feedback

Sun errs?

  • Story Link
  • 9

Categories

By FERN SHEN
Baltimore Sun management described its massive layoffs yesterday – 61 editorial-side staffers cut, a third of the 205-person newsroom – as a strategy for “success, not just survival, ” part of their transition into  ”a 24-hour local news-gathering media company.”

These brief comments in a small story on the Sun’s business page were pretty much all the explanation they were offering.

((UPDATE: Sun publisher Tim Ryan today sent a memo to staff   ‘regretting’ the impact of layoffs, explaining they’re part of a restructuring that will leave them better positioned to “help our company succeed and win in the future.”  Click through to read it.))

Brutal though it is, they seem to be saying, it’s the only way. Will Baltimore buy that?

Making a virtue of necessity is, of course, what management does at a time like this, though it was surely cold comfort for the casualties of “transition.” Sportswriters Rick Maese and David Steele and others got the word while covering a game at Camden Yards. Editor Patricia Fanning got it while editing a story.

“Colleagues cheered and applauded staffers leaving the building” after learning their fate, according to former Sun rewrite man David Ettlin.

Ettlin did a terrific job of gathering these poignant stories, the kind replayed, really, across the city and across the country at brokerage firms, restaurants, auto plants, landscaping companies — all the places where jobs have been disintegrating.

And that’s management’s rationale for the massacre: the economy did it. And the Internet. Sun editor J. Montgomery “Monty” Cook laid it out in a speech recently at Johns Hopkins.

Questions for Monty
Cook and the handful of others remaining on the masthead have not made themselves available to answer questions (the complany shut out a radio reporter yesterday, forbidding him from interviewing a Guild representative in the Sun building’s lobby.)

But Sun managers would probably say, if you cornered one in an elevator: ‘It stinks but revenue’s in the toilet and eyeballs have moved to the Internet and what else could we have done?’ They’d point out that the website is growing traffic numbers, if not revenue.

So, what do you say back, at that point, Brew readers?

‘Why are you decimating the thing instead of selling it?’

‘Why do you put great editors and writers out on the street and continue to produce the money-losing “b?” (Need we remind readers about the infamous ”Douchebag!” cover piece?)

Send us your thoughts (click the teeny tiny comment bubble at the top right-hand side of this post.) What would you say to Monty Cook or Tim Ryan?

——-

Here is Ryan’s memo:

From: “Ryan, Tim” tim.ryan@baltsun.com
Date: Thu, 30 Apr 2009 07:44:52 -0700

Conversation: Message from Tim Ryan

Subject: Message from Tim Ryan

To All Employees:

Over the past year we at The Baltimore Sun Media Group (BSMG) have made many changes to help our company succeed and win in the future. One of these changes is restructuring our newsroom so we can more effectively gather content and distribute it to our readers in ways they choose. Unfortunately, this also meant that we had to layoff a number of people. These are always difficult decisions, and we regret the impact they have on staff and their families.

It is important for you to know that The Baltimore Sun will continue to have as many news reporters covering the region as before. We retain, by far, the largest news-gathering staff in Maryland, three times as large as any other competitor. Our news reporters will be deployed strategically to provide 24-hour news with a focus on local community issues and events, as well as “watchdog” investigative reporting.

Our future lies in our ability to develop and deliver quality content across many platforms to many diverse audiences. While The Baltimore Sun and baltimoresun.com remain an integral part of BSMG, we also publish 28 local community newspapers, b, our free publication for young adults, magazines, specialty publications and other Web sites. Every week, 9 out of 10 households receive at least one BSMG product.

The changes we are making – with the continued support of our entire team here at BSMG – will ensure that we are able to provide current and future generations of readers with the same outstanding news and information we have for the past 171 years.

  • Larry Harris

    The terrible irony of this whole monstrous breakdown is that 40 years ago — in hot metal and the first cold-type days — many of us were regarded as one-man staffs who made assignments, read wires, edited stories, did layouts, chose and cropped pictures, wrote cutlines and headlines, then went downstairs to the composing room and supervised the makeup. . . mostly in a 4-hour window at The Evening Sun. I wonder if Chicago needs a 72-year-old retiree who can still do it all!!!!!!

  • Bob Erlandson

    As I recall The Sun of 1955 and look at what’s left of The Sun in 2009 one phrase leaps to mind: FUBAR.

    My fear as The Sun goes down the drain is the same as when the papers in Seattle and Denver closed: Political corruption and police tyranny will increase unchecked because there is no one to watch them and expose it publicly.

    TV is incapable of doing it; radio hasn’t the resources to do it and bloggers are not the answer. This was a function unique to newspapers.

    The hired guns currently running The Sun are trying to spin this disaster as the first positive step to a new Sun.

    BS!!!

    Long ago they eliminated the historical memory of The Sun newsroom and now they simply won’t have the bodies to do the serious job of local journalism.

    For Baltimore this is a tragedy greater than we yet know. But its impact will become increasingly clear as The Sun continues to set.

  • Debbie Jones

    From Tim Ryan’s memo: Every week, 9 out of 10 households receive at least one BSMG product.

    When a newspaper becomes a product, it is no surprise that quality suffers.

  • Battered Sun survivor

    Ryan writes: “It is important for you to know that The Baltimore Sun will continue to have as many news reporters covering the region as before.”

    I’d like to know what “before” means to our publisher. A week ago? A month? Sun readers, and those who work and worked at The Sun have better long-term memory, I guess. And of course the number of editors, photographers and artists who have been slashed is irrelevant to this Orwellian pronouncement.

  • Baltimore Guy

    How feasible is it for the Washington Post to distribute a Maryland edition in Baltimore? I would subscribe today; I don’t even care if it took them a year to create a Baltimore bureau. I just want a daily paper every morning, and I can’t stomach buying The Sun any longer.

  • WildBillFan

    I just can’t see the Sun surviving in print with what skeletal staff they have left. And the suits won’t care. Digital only, baby, that’s where our young, hip readers are. Except they aren’t, and they aren’t buying, and you aren’t making a damn bit of money off them. … Anyone who sees any value in producing b, or who signed off on the Sun’s past two horrendous redesigns, is so out of touch they can’t be reasoned with.

  • Mike Bowler

    I’ve just been sick at heart for a week and appreciating your filling in the blanks. Baltimore Guy is way off base. The WP is a disaster also and will never establish a Balto. bureau. Anyway, how can I get your service daily, Fern? Tonight it’s shut off. “About Us” and “Subscribe” are nonresponsive. Hope this gets through.

    • Editor

      Hi Mike, I’m glad you’re finding some useful or helpful stuff on our site…. I am working hard to make Brew better and better and am glad so many good people are helping. Let me check into why you can’t get onto these pages. You should be able to subscribe to our RSS feed. I’ll get back to you when i figure it out…..

  • Another Sun Survivor

    A victim of their mass layoff’s at the end of 2008, I can’t believe they are still shaving the staff down each month. My former department (that was already barebones) is down to 1. I’d hate the be that guy who’s left. It’s only a matter of time, right?

    I loved The Sun and am sicked watching it crumble. I still get my home delivery but consider cancelling every single day. It never arrives even close to on time, never before I leave for work at my NEW job, and no amount of complaints seem to generate a result. By the time I get home it IS old news and I don’t want it then.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • January 27, 2012

    • Catching up on a slew of interesting things to do and read this weekend that we almost lost track of in the Kickstarter hub-bub. Here are just a few: SATURDAY (1/28/12) New Mercury Non-fiction Reading – Check out tell-it-like-it-is education blogger Edit Barry (see below) and a pack of other feisty non-fictional characters from the [...]

Twitter

Facebook