Feedback

Baltimore waterfront will be traffic hell, before it ever becomes transit heaven, City predicts

  • Story Link
  • 2

Categories

City transportation officials are sending out mixed signals about the future of transportation in the City’s waterfront corridor.
On the same day that the Sun is reporting the City government’s success in extending its Tide Point water taxi service which now handles 90 riders per day, the Baltimore Guide informs us that the city anticipates 20,000 new automobile trips in the waterfront corridor in the afternoon and evening peak period alone, according to Jessica Keller, the City’s Chief of Transportation Planning.
Keller uses this projection in her support of the Red Line transit project, stating “It would be ideal to have the county commuters  get out of their cars at Canton Crossing and board the Red Line eliminating clogged roadway and smelly gas fumes along the corridor.”
What she does not say is that the Red Line will not be completed by the projected 2012 date of the City’s projected new 20,000 car influx, and that the Red Line’s construction period will significantly reduce traffic lane capacity in the corridor during the interim period.
Keller also touts the existing #11 MTA bus service in the Red Line corridor, saying it takes her only eight minutes to get from Canton to the central business district, citing only the “stigma attached to it” for her previous resistance to using it.
So if the existing surface bus service is so great, why do we need to build a $1.6 Billion underground Red Line?
By GERALD NEILY
City transportation officials are sending out mixed signals about the future of transportation in the City’s waterfront corridor. One minute they’re touting the success of a few new boat riders, the next minute they’re predicting impending street traffic Armageddon.
A day after The Baltimore Sun reported the City government’s success in expanding its Tide Point water taxi service (which now handles just 90 riders per day), the Baltimore Guide informs us that the city anticipates 20,000 new automobile trips in the southeast waterfront corridor in the afternoon and evening peak period alone. This according to Jessica Keller, the City’s Chief of Transportation Planning who also identifies herself, in a letter to the paper, as a Canton resident.
She continues: “By comparison, the typial gateway corridor in Baltimore City – Reisterstown Road, Harford Road – carries approximately 20,000 vehicle trips in a 24-hour period per day! Try crossing Boston Street then !”
Keller uses this projection in her support of the Red Line transit project, stating “It would be ideal to have the county commuters  get out of their cars at Canton Crossing and board the Red Line eliminating clogged roadway and smelly gas fumes along the corridor.”
What she does not say is that the Red Line will not be completed by the 2012 date of the City’s projected new 20,000 car influx, and that the Red Line’s construction period will significantly reduce traffic capacity in the corridor during the interim period.
Keller also touts the existing #11 MTA bus service in the Red Line corridor, saying it takes her only eight minutes to get from Canton to the central business district. (She cites only the “stigma attached to it” for her previous resistance to using it.)
So if the existing surface bus service is so great, why do we need to build a $1.6 Billion underground Red Line?
Keller’s comments are contained in a letter responding to an article written by Baltimore Guide Editor Jacqueline Watts in the July 1 issue. Watts’ article claims that “MTA representatives say that while the plan, which they call Alternative 4C, is not perfect, it is cheaper, and falls within federal mass transit cost guidelines.”
This, however, is not true. Alternative 4C, which Keller also calls the “preferred alternative” for the Red Line, fails to satisfy the federal cost guidelines.
  • Jessica Keller

    The City actually is not sending mixed signals at all; please see the Southeast Transportation Action Plan at http://www.ci.baltimore.md.us/government/transportation/downloads/0508/SETransportation_bro_revised%20(3).pdf

    The widely distributed 2007 plan was developed to respond to the impending traffic woes that will result from development west of Canton in Fells Point, Harbor East and Harbor Point.

    The new water taxi service, the re-routed #11 bus and the Red Line are three of many recommendations outlined in the plan

    What the City IS doing is executing a plan to alleviate projected congestion.

  • geraldneily

    Thank you for the reply, Ms. Keller, and for including a link to the City’s report, upon which your comments were based.

    Here is a summary of the 14 page report. There are no contradictions to anything I said.

    Pages 1-5: Messages from Mayor Dixon and Director Al Foxx, Acknowledgements, Introduction and Public Input.

    Page 6-8: Description of Growth, Development and Traffic Growth Projections. The exact reference to traffic growth is: “More than 20,000 projected new private vehicular trips in the critical afternoon/evening peak hours are anticipated.”

    Page 9: Recommendations. The first sentence of the two paragraphs is: “In the short-term, the lack of strong public transportation in Southeast Baltimore significantly restricts the likelihood of a shift to public transportation for many of the projected 20,000 new peak hour trips.”

    Page 9-10: Road and Intersection Improvements: These are to accommodate the traffic, not reduce it or shift it to another mode.

    Page 11-14: Transit, Water Taxi, Traffic Management, Demand Reduction Strategies, Bicycle Travel, Managing Truck Traffic, Parking and Car Sharing. None of these are quantified in any way, as acknowledged in the Recommendations section.

    Page 14: Long-Term Outlook (stated as being “beyond 2012″). This is where the Red Line is cited, as well as a new MARC station and additional roadway expansions.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • January 27, 2012

    • Catching up on a slew of interesting things to do and read this weekend that we almost lost track of in the Kickstarter hub-bub. Here are just a few: SATURDAY (1/28/12) New Mercury Non-fiction Reading – Check out tell-it-like-it-is education blogger Edit Barry (see below) and a pack of other feisty non-fictional characters from the [...]

Twitter

Facebook