Feedback

Tempers flare at Sparrows Point pollution meeting

Residents complain of slow pace of the steel mill’s compliance with a 1997 environmental consent decree.

Sparrows Point 1954 2

Sparrows Point in 1954 when hazardous wastes were dumped with abandon along the waterfront.

Photo by: Bethlehem Steel

  • Story Link
  • 17

Categories

“What you’re hearing is a lot of frustration,” said Harry Wujek, president of the North Point Peninsula Community Coordinating Council, summing up the sentiments of about 30 people attending last night’s hearing on the status of environmental work at the Sparrows Point steel mill.

Some expressed disappointment – others flashes of anger – when told by Andrew Fan, project manager for the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), that developing a plan for sampling offshore mill contamination was still a year from starting and that a human health risk assessment is not expected to be completed until 2012.

“No backdoor deals – they have to clean up,” exclaimed Guido Guarnaccia, a Back River resident who instigated a citizens’ suit that led to the 1997 consent decree between Bethlehem Steel Corp. and EPA and the Maryland Department of the Environment (MDE) to clean up decades of pollution at the steel mill.

Fan indicated that the biggest challenge facing regulators is containing a “very large hydrocarbon plume” that lies underneath an abandoned coke-oven facility.

Calling the plume “very similar in composition to the oil spill in the Gulf Coast,” the viscous slick, with high levels of benzene and naphthalene, has seeped into the groundwater and is now migrating into Baltimore’s Outer Harbor and toward Bear Creek.

As reported last November by the Brew, EPA and MDE were aware of the spreading plume since 2005, when it was disclosed in a study by an environmental consultant, URS Corp.

Samples found benzene levels as high as 158,000 times above EPA’s standard for drinking water. But it was not until February 2009 that EPA told current mill owner Severstal to undertake corrective action.

This month, Severstal installed the first of six remediation cells that Fan estimated would recover “a few thousand gallons” of benzene and naphthalene vapors per month by July 2011.

His remarks led David Janiszewski to ask, “Why only six cells? Why not 20?”

Fan did not respond.

Bear Creek resident Bill Pribyl expressed frustration at EPA’s lack of zeal. “Jesus, fix it. Time is critical. I want to see these problems fixed in my generation. But I don’t see that here. And that’s shocking.”

New Landfill Sought

Annoyance was followed by astonishment when the audience was told that Severstal filed an application last week for a new industrial landfill at Sparrows Point.

The disclosure came as part of a discussion about Greys Landfill, an unlined landfill that was “grandfathered” into the consent decree.

Barbara Brown, an MDE official, said the landfill has undergone many improvements, including new berms and stormwater storage basins, but acknowledged that several monitoring wells around the landfill’s perimeter have detected elevated levels of hazardous chemicals.

Gloria Nelson, a resident of Turners Station, appeared stunned. “We live right across Bear Creek from this landfill. We did not have any input on the landfill as we saw it materialize.”

She and other residents had been under the impression that the landfill did not leak. “Now I hear there is leakage. This leakage may be going into Bear Creek. How is it that MDE knows this, and now the company wants to be permitted an additional landfill?” She shook her head in disbelief.

Louis Konopacki, who crabs on Bear Creek, complained that Greys Landfill routinely emits foul odors. Mitch McCalmon, an MDE official, invited residents to file complaints with MDE if they smelled anything bad, promising a vigorous investigation.

Severstal to Involve Community

Russell Becker, an environmental engineer for Severstal, did not comment on the odors, but stated that the proposed landfill would be lined and include various protections against the leaching of chemicals.

He said Severstal is committed to involving the community in the planning process. A new landfill would allow the phase-out and permanent capping of Greys Landfill, which will reach its legal height of 140 feet in about four years.

The timing of Severstal’s application baffled state Senator Norman R. Stone.

“This is a company that’s cutting back on production, laying off people and importing steel from overseas. Now it wants to put in a new landfill? I just don’t get it,” he commented after the meeting.

- Reach Mark Reutter at reuttermark@yahoo.com.

  • http://twitter.com/rkolberg rkolberg

    EPA: Sparrows Point plume very similar in composition to Gulf oil spill. So why no action for > 13 years?! EPA, MDE, CBF must step up to the plate NOW. #chesbay

  • Jim Turner

    I hope the plant does go out of business. We really need to shed a light on these horribly polluting factories destroying our harbor. our air would be so much cleaner and water too if we didnt have this mill. Look at the buildings themselves in the complex… its just not worth it.

  • Jim Turner

    I hope the plant does go out of business. We really need to shed a light on these horribly polluting factories destroying our harbor. our air would be so much cleaner and water too if we didnt have this mill. Look at the buildings themselves in the complex… its just not worth it.

    • Gary G

      So you want to get rid of 2000 good paying jobs and the other businesses that support the mill?

    • forrest

      do you even know how hard it would be for the 2000 plus workers to find a job in todays market. why dont you come down here and see how hard we work to put food on the table. your an asshole. dont you know the the ownership of the point has changed names 3 times in the last 10 yrs. its not thw workers falt. it was beth steels falt from the begining. i hope that you lose your job and see you try to put food on the table.

    • jjazz2099

      Get a LIFE ! Count Your BLESSINGS you are here today. My guess is that you were born with a golden spoon in your mouth. And that you do not know very much. when you go green perhaps you may loose your job.All of us!

      • Gumpworks

        go gettem jazz

    • M O G

      Excuse me sir are you kidding!!!! Don't you know that it's never good for an plant that has been the backbone of our state; even before you were born to go out of business. That type of thinking is plain crazy, but i guess you work in the corporate world huh? Without this plant around those same guys WILL BE ROBBING YOU AT GUNPOINT TOMORROW; BUT I'M SURE YOU HAVE A.D.T RIGHT!!!!

  • Gary G

    So you want to get rid of 2000 good paying jobs and the other businesses that support the mill?

  • jjazz2099

    Get a LIFE ! Count Your BLESSINGS you are here today. My guess is that you were born with a golden spoon in your mouth. And that you do not know very much. when you go green perhaps you may loose your job.All of us!

  • walter

    Senator – the company can make millions from the landfill – pollution haulers from all over the USA and even abroad will pay to use this harzardous materials dump.

    Now- do you get it? This will bring in much needed money for the plant's owners and at the same time safely dispose of harardous waste.

  • M O G

    Excuse me sir are you kidding!!!! Don't you know that it's never good for an plant that has been the backbone of our state; even before you were born to go out of business. That type of thinking is plain crazy, but i guess you work in the corporate world huh? Without this plant around those same guys WILL BE ROBBING YOU AT GUNPOINT TOMORROW; BUT I'M SURE YOU HAVE A.D.T RIGHT!!!!

  • Gumpworks

    go gettem jazz

  • Kate

    Severstal Sparrows Point has an Environmental Complaint Hotline that's manned 24/7. Phone Number is 410-388-5000. You can submit your complaint anonymously.

  • rkolberg

    If a burglar was breaking into your home would you call the burglar's cell phone?????

    If someone observes air or water pollution coming from Severstal or any other source, call the Maryland Department of the Environment's 24-hour line at (866) 633-4686. You can also file a complaint via MDE's website, http://www.mde.state.md.us/ContactUs/reportpoll…

  • Ou812

    Environmental Hotline at the Point?????

    • Kate

      There's even an Environmental Dept. @ Sparrows Point ;)

      This Hotline is dedicated to handling calls involving the following:
      1. Spills
      a. Defined as the loss of control or release of a substance to the ground, sewer or waterway regardless of the amount or nature of the substance.
      b. Spills must be reported to the appropriate government agency within two hours of their discovery.
      c. It is the responsibility of the person who caused or discovered the spill to contact Environmental Hotline or Sparrows Point Police Department and Desk Officer will contact Environmental Personnel with the following information:
      • What was spilled and in what quantity?
      • The location of the spill.
      • The cause of the spill.
      • Did the spilled material enter the water or a sewer?
      • Is the material contained?
      • Is the source under control?
      • Has cleanup begun?
      • The name and phone number of a person to contact for follow up information.
      2. Scrap Tire Emergencies
      a. In the event of a fire, flood, or other problem relating to scrap tires Environmental must be notified.
      b. Remember that your obligation has not been met until you contact an environmental person.
      c. Contact with an answering machine is not sufficient.
      3. Hot Metal Dumping
      a. Whenever hot metal is dumped, we must notify the Maryland Department of the Environment. Environmental will make this notification after it is notified of the dumping incident.
      b. The following information is necessary when a hot metal dumping report is made to Environmental.
      • Date of dumping
      • Time of dumping
      • The identification number of each sub that was dumped. If this is not available, the total number of subs dumped will be sufficient.
      • The location where the dumping occurred
      • The name and phone number of the person making the report
      c. Notification of hot metal dumping does NOT have to be done immediately.
      d. As soon as possible after the dumping is completed, you may call extension 5991 and make the report. You may leave the information on the answering machine if no one is available to take your call.

      4. Excess Air Emissions from Installations
      a. Excess emissions are defined as an emission rate, which exceeds any applicable emission standard currently in effect.
      b. Report equipment excess emissions to Environmental personnel between 7:30 AM and 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday, holidays excluded.
      c. If excess emissions occur during other times, report them the next scheduled workday.
      d. If you cannot contact someone, it is acceptable to leave your information on the answering machine. Environmental personnel will get back to you to confirm receipt of your call.
      5. Air Pollution Abatement Equipment Malfunctions
      a. A malfunction is defined as the sudden and unavoidable failure of an installation to operate in a normal and usual manner.
      b. If a mill's abatement equipment or portion thereof, is out of service for one hour or more, the Maryland Department of the Environment (MDE) must be notified.
      c. Environmental personnel will make the contact with the MDE but it is up to the operating department to contact Environmental personnel first.
      d. When a malfunction occurs Environmental should be provided with the following information
      • The identity of the equipment involved and a description of the incident.
      • The time the incident began and the expected length of the outage.
      • The time the incident concluded.
      • A person to contact for follow up information.
      e. Report equipment malfunctions to Environmental personnel between 7:30 AM and 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday, holidays excluded
      f. If a malfunction occurs during other times report it the next scheduled workday.
      6. NPDES Permit Effluent Limitations Exceedences
      a. All instances of exceedences of NPDES permit limitations are to be reported. You should be prepared to discuss the date, time, parameters, and quantities involved in the incident.
      b. Report NPDES exceedences to Environmental personnel between 7:30 AM and 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday, holidays excluded.
      c. If a NPDES non-compliance occurs during other times, report it the next scheduled workday.
      7. Water Pollution Control Treatment Facility Bypasses
      a. a. Bypassing of treatment facilities necessary to maintain compliance with the terms and conditions of our NPDES permit is prohibited unless:
      • The bypass is unavoidable to prevent loss of life, personal injury, substantial physical damage to property, damage to the treatment facility which would cause it to become inoperable, or substantial and permanent loss of natural resources;
      • There are no feasible alternatives;
      • Notification is received by the Maryland Department of the Environment (MDE) within 24 hours (if orally notified, then followed by a written submission within five days) of the permittee's becoming aware of the bypass. Where the need for a bypass is anticipated in advance a notification must be submitted to MDE ten days prior to the date of the bypass

      • The bypass is allowed under conditions determined by MDE to be necessary to minimize adverse effects.
      b. Any treatment facility bypass must be reported to Environmental immediately
      c. To report a treatment facility bypass contact Environmental personnel between 7:30 AM and 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday, holidays excluded.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • January 27, 2012

    • Catching up on a slew of interesting things to do and read this weekend that we almost lost track of in the Kickstarter hub-bub. Here are just a few: SATURDAY (1/28/12) New Mercury Non-fiction Reading – Check out tell-it-like-it-is education blogger Edit Barry (see below) and a pack of other feisty non-fictional characters from the [...]

Twitter

Facebook