Feedback

Homeless have been sleeping on clinic’s porch for months

"It tears me up inside," says clinic's president.

hch3

Health Care for the Homeless has been letting people sleep on their porch for months. Shown here: eight people under blankets on the night of Dec. 28th.

Photo by: Fern Shen

  • Story Link
  • 13

Categories

The jarring sight we saw in the wee hours of the morning Thursday at Baltimore’s new $15.5 million homeless services clinic – eight people sleeping in barely above freezing temperatures outside the building on its “front porch” – was not unusual, it seems.

Kevin Lindamood, president and CEO of Health Care for the Homeless (HCH), said people began sleeping outside their building at 421 Fallsway a year ago – and the “porch population” that has been coming there ever since is “not static.”

Caseworkers are assigned to the people who turn up, meet regularly with them and often manage to find them a bed somewhere in town, Lindamood said.

But new people keep coming.

“We’ve had couples, we recently had two women and, at one point, we had a woman who was eight months pregnant,” he said, adding that the staff of the clinic (it is not a shelter) eventually found her a place to stay that was out of the elements.

The first person to camp out on the porch had been an undocumented immigrant and so, reluctant to involve the police, the staff had allowed the man to stay while they tried to get him counseling and other help.

As the porch encampment grew into a steady phenomenon, HCH enhanced the lighting there and installed security cameras and signs to make the area more secure, Lindamood said.

But he acknowledged that it is troubling to have people sleeping on the cold cement on the very doorstep of an institution dedicated to helping such men and women.

Recently, an eight-months pregnant woman was among the people sleeping outside this Baltimore homeless services clinic. (Photo by Fern Shen)

An eight-months pregnant woman was among the people recently sleeping outside this Baltimore homeless services clinic. (Photo by Fern Shen)

“It frustrates the hell out of us,” Lindamood said. The current thinking in the city and among many homeless service providers, he noted, is that the focus should shift away from emergency shelter and more toward permanent housing solutions, making condoning the porch people “fairly controversial.”

“But the only way to not have people sleeping on the porch would be to physically prevent it and that’s not in keeping with our mission – to put a gate up out there wouldn’t be right,” Lindamood said.

“And yet, I mean, we are helping people to sleep on our porch! It tears me up inside.”

More Need, but Fewer Beds

So why can’t a building full of social workers practically next door to the city shelter get these people in out of the elements?

The $8 million, 250-bed Harry and Jeanette Weinberg Housing and Resource Center, to the consternation of homeless advocates, opened in June with 100 fewer beds than the shelter building it replaced. Has that been a factor?

Lindamood offered a number of reasons for the steady stream of people turning up on HCH’s front stoop, including the relative safety of the building. “On top of the [fact that it's got] lights, it’s near the city [motor pool] gas station, so a lot of police cars go by,” he said. “They feel safer there.” He also noted that people with mental health, behavioral or addiction issues are sometimes less likely to wind up in a shelter.

But pressed on the role fewer city shelter beds might play in boosting the porch count, Lindamood said, “we have had people who said they’d been turned away” from there. (Sources have told The Brew the porch encampment really surged in the summer, around the time of the switchover to the new city shelter, a.k.a. “Code Blue.”)

Lindamood went on to observe, in an interview last Friday, that the city shelter “was at capacity last night. That tells you something.”

He noted that all of the 100 additional overflow beds available for men, and 19 of the 20 overflow beds available for women were full. Also full were the shelter’s day rooms, where city officials have now received permission from fire officials to house 60 people at night.

Mural on the wall of Health  Care for the Homeless building. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Mural on the wall of Health Care for the Homeless building. Yesterday seven people were found camped out on the building's "front porch" in the late afternoon. (Photo by Mark Reutter)

Phone messages left Friday for Homeless Services Director Kate Bridell and for Thomasina “Tomi” Hiers, deputy chief of staff for Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, were not returned.

The downsized and filled-up city shelter is only one piece of the problem.

Across the city, shelter beds made available by a number of providers for Baltimore’s growing homeless population are inadequate to meet the need. There are about 2,000 emergency and transitional shelter beds at the moment and at last count, in January 2011, there were 4,088 people homeless.

There are people sleeping outside all over Baltimore, including this person under the JFX across the street from Health Care for the Homeless. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Someone sleeping under the JFX across the street from Health Care for the Homeless. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Coming to Shelters “Wide-Eyed”

Advocates believe that the official counts underestimate the problem and that, over the course of a year, 40,000 people will experience homelessness in Baltimore.

“There are people sleeping outside all over the city,” Lindamood said, describing the shift in the kinds of people seeking shelter and services these days.

“The traditional shelter client was a single man. Now you’re seeing mom and dad and two kids sleeping on a bench,” he said. “You have people who’ve never been at a shelter before. They’re coming in wide-eyed.”

Baltimore Brew is a moderated site that encourages the free and open exchange of ideas in a climate of mutual respect. We reserve the right - but do not assume any obligation - to delete or withhold the publication of comments that violate our standards. Comments that are obscene, libelous or defamatory, or include vicious personal attacks will not be published. Racist remarks, sexist remarks, disgusting stuff, blatant commercial self-promotion – you get the idea – if it crosses our line, we’re not going to run it.

  • A very concerned citizen

    My heart goes out to those who have no home.  My head tells me do not ask the Lord to guide your footsteps if you are not willing to move your feet.  This is my dilemma.

    • Devil’s Advocate

      Are you saying don’t help those that don’t help themselves?

      • A very concerned citizen

        Not at all, Devil am I saying that.
        What I am saying is one can stand on their head to try to help someone, but if that someone doesn’t want the help, it is a waste of time.  There is a huge difference between people who can not help themselves and those who will not help themselves.

    • Coolrevchick

      I am a Christian weary of all of our non-biblical rhetoric when I hear this association of shelter, work, and worth. 

      Matthew 25:35 “…’for I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, I was naked and you gave mc clothing, I was sick and you took care of me, I was in prison and you visited me.’” 

      Jesus didn’t require an application, a picture i.d., a W-2, or even a sign that says “will work for food” in order for help to be given to the suffering and the marginalized. The Bible overwhelmingly sides with the poor, the hunger, the bereft, and (yes) the unemployed. Ever read the Book of Ruth? Support your opinion however you choose, but I would prefer that I don’t bring incoherent and indefensible theology into your argument. 

  • Baltimoreplaces

    In Baltimore we have a lot vacant housing.  At the same time we have a $26M Federal grant to rehabilitate housing that is going to waste.  There probably is a way, through a non-profit, to use this money to create halfway housing.

    Halfway housing seems to provide a way up and out for many folks.  Between 1000′s of city owned homes in desperate need of renovations and homeless needing a place to live there seems to be a solution here. 

  • Unellu

    Put your head where your heart is concerned citizen.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1510154191 David Kennedy

      @Devil:twitter Unellu, a facile answer to CCitizen’s serious point, which you ignore.
      @Devil:twitter , an Olympic-worthy leap into the unknown.  CC’s point was clear to me: there are at least 4 types of homeless:
      [a] those who prefer it [a minority, to be sure],
      [b] those who will not follow the rules [more of them than you would suppose],
      [c] those who cannot follow the rules [mental instability],
      [d] those who have been hit hard by the latest economic fallout.
      I speak from experience, for whatever that’s worth.
      The central point is real: there were at that time [mid-80's] plenty of overnighters who would spend the morning at the McD’s on Fayette, then mosey on up to St Iggies on Calvert or Daily Bread on Franklin, then work their way back to Central Avenue for the evening repast.  The majority could have worked, they had no [discernable] mental or physical issues.  On the contrary, many were in better shape than me.But….what do i know?

  • Unellu

    Thanks for your stratification David Kennedy–I am sure there are as many types of  homeless as there are people with and in homes.  There are whole lot of people who have homes who sleep out in tents, on mountain tops and  on rocky ledges just for the experience, the thrill, and the fun of it.  I see what you are saying though–you are saying some prefer to be homeless and others are homeless because when a roof is placed over their heads, rules, restrictions and regulations follow and rules and regulations are not exactly honey and milk to those folks.  But we don’t know that the ones who are sleeping outside Healthcare for the Homeless belong in any one of these categories–the unruly, the unstable, the irresponsible or the unsalvageable homeless.  If you are homeless and regulation free long enough you get used to it.  If society scorns you and ignores you long enough then you don’t see any purpose in living by the rules of society and you will wind up not trusting the great civilization around you.  To bring the homeless within four walls is a long and arduous task.  The homeless will probably suffer the anxieties of being in bound and may even have claustrophobia when they are watched and regulated every step of the way.  Those who want to eradicate homelessness cannot get exasperated.  You have claimed experience in this area.  You should know better than others, that the rehabilitation process is probably excruciating for those who have been homeless for a long time–I am sure they have remarkably repetitive routine– the homeless–like the ones you describe–I am sure they are habituated to certain migratory paths within the areas they inhabit and forage in–when you are breaking habits you may run up against walls, yet it would be a sad black mark on a society if it gave up and did not try to bring these folks in from the cold, at least during the most brutal phases of the winter.  I didn’t say the homeless are perfect (are we, the ones in homes, perfect?).  I only said we have to stop the intellectualizing and the “blame the victims” attitude.  We have to do what we can with the full knowledge we may fail for no fault of our own or no fault of the homeless.  Sometimes that’s the way the chips fall.  Homelessness may be a way of life too hard to break.         

  • Anonymous

    coolrevchick,
    Yours is an interesting comment.  I am not a Christian but all the religions of the world pay homage to the poor and the hungry, admonishing the rest of society to care for them unconditionally.  The Christian religion, in particular, is founded on charity, generosity, redemption and hope.  But many on these forums would argue that even god helps only those who will help themselves.  And even if we argue back that the homeless are not able to help themselves, they would reply that the addicted homeless can and should kick their addictions and the homeless who hate obeying rules should set aside their rebellion and fit in. 
    On a lighter note I recently saw an old movie with Tony Randall and Rock Hudson in it–Tony Randall is a rich and lame character in the movie and he complains loudly about his feelings of isolation and abandonment.  When asked how he could possibly feel so despondent when he is so rich, he replies how all the great books, poems and verses glorify the poor as opposed to the rich whom they either leave out or vilify.  For example he asks, “Give me your poor etc is what it says doesn’t it, not give me your rich and so on?”  Apparently the rich, as they cavort, feel condemned by the holy books and feel utterly rejected by verse and song.  We may shun the poor but nevertheless we are convinced the gods love the poor unconditionally.  Apparently the rich envy the poor their imagined place in the kingdom of heaven, their lionization in legend and their canonization in the scriptures. 
    Not too long ago while I was traveling by bus in India, I sat next to a poor vegetable vendor.  She began chatting with me in Tamil, a South Indian language.  Most vegetable vendors in India live in thatched roof homes for which they pay subsidized rent.  The woman pointed to a beggar on the street and bemoaned her own fate.  She told me she wished she were a beggar because she said, “Look how easy his life–he does not have to eke out a living selling vegetables like I do–he sleeps on the streets–he does not pay rent or electricity bills and he does not have creditors knocking on his door dunning him for cash.”  I am sure, though, if I had robbed her vegetable basket, she would have come after me with a vengeance to get it back.  Wistfully wishing for poverty is never the same as embracing it. 
    Somehow even the poor think of abject poverty as a state of irresponsibility.  But one of my favorite panhandlers in India–a woman I gave to during my college days–she always begged at the bus stop where I boarded my bus–she told me that begging is a difficult “profession”.  She needed to beat the other beggars to her favorite spots– competition being stifling, she needed to cultivate her own philanthropists–which she did by narrating stories to her givers, telling them jokes and blessing them each time she received anything from them.  This woman knew me by name, always inquired after my family, knew when I had tough exams to write, asked me how I fared in those exams and followed my fate through my graduation from college and my exit to America.  Each time I returned to India for a visit, I went looking for her at the same bus stop.  By the way, she never wanted to be rescued.  She was proud of what she did and how she conducted herself while doing it.  Those who gave to her were literally her clients and her customers.  It broke my heart that I never did find her when I went visiting.
    On the same note, during a conversation with a fat cat doctor from Argentina, I asked what he thought of the dismal plight of the Indians in South America–shouldn’t they be uplifted–he told me he didn’t see why their plight should be improved–after all in places like Peru they were happy chewing their coca leaves and lying around–this man, who wouldn’t give up a cent of his hoarded wealth was convinced that the indigent Indians of South America live in a state of carefree bliss and should be left undisturbed in that Nirvana.  Across the world there are many perceptions of poverty not in sync with US views on the subject.            

  • Gerald Neily

    Wonderful discussion here, showing again how Brew readers are the best !!! I think all this also shows how the city’s goal to end homelessness in ten years is just the usual hype, like doubling the tree canopy, doubling transit ridership, ending harbor pollution, cutting taxes and growing the population. 

  • Scarlet1959

    How can whoever possibly condone building a 15 million dollar building for services, and an 8 million dollar building for beds??? Especially since they cut the number of beds! There is really something wrong with that picture!

    • Anonymous

      From B Brew: The $15m Health Care for Homeless clinic (non-city) does medical and other outreach services; the $8m shelter (city-owned and operated by JHR, Inc.) is billed as a “resource center” as well as emergency shelter. It features a clinic as well as “day rooms” for clients seeking jobs and housing assistance.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

    • Yesterday, when Baltimore web developer and Ignite Baltimore co-founder Mike Subelsky tweeted that he was about to witness Nik Wallenda’s tightrope walk across the Inner Harbor, my ears perked up. Pix to come, Subelsky promised. Oooh, send them along I said! Recognizing his citizen journalist moment, Subelsky kindly agreed and sent along some great photos. [...]

Twitter

Facebook