Feedback

RG Steel’s bankruptcy yields a feast of billable hours

44 members of New York law firm charge up to $1,090 an hour handling first month of Chapter 11 case.

Shaunna Jones Stacy London

New York lawyer Shaunna Jones, seen here in a Stacy London wardrobe makeover, billed $163,530 for one-month’s work on RG Steel’s bankruptcy.

Photo by: health.com

Fear not for the attorneys handling the Chapter 11 case of RG Steel.

The steel mills at Sparrows Point and elsewhere may be closed and facing an uncertain future, but the lawyers are taking good care of themselves.

So good that they are billing the bankrupt company as much as $1,090 an hour and charging in increments of 0.1 hour (every six minutes) of work.

Federal law gives the payment of lawyer’s fees priority over nearly every other party in a bankruptcy case – including Baltimore City and County, collectively owed $11.8 million, and the 3,000 steelworkers laid off at Sparrows Point, Warren, Ohio, and Wheeling, W.Va.

Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP of Manhattan took full advantage of that stipulation yesterday.

The law firm submitted a bill of $1,350,137 for its first month as company co-counsel (May 31-June 30), with another $31,795.83 in expenses.

Papers filed at U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Wilmington revealed that four lawyers billed more than $600,000 in fees for June – and that summer interns each received $275 an hour.

Matthew A. Feldman charged more than $140,000 in legal fees in June. (Photo courtesy of Willkie, Farr & Gallagher)

Lawyer Matthew A. Feldman charged more than $140,000 in June. (Photo courtesy of Willkie, Farr & Gallagher)

Altogether, Willkie Farr said it used 44 firm members (8 partners, 20 associates, 9 legal assistants and 7 summer interns) to work on the case, racking up 2,199.5 billable hours.

Leading the list of rainmakers was Shaunna D. Jones, a New York University Law School grad who recently became a partner in the firm. She billed $163,530 for 207 hours at $790 an hour.

She was followed by Andrew Sorkin ($163,215 for 251 hours and 6 minutes), senior partner Matthew A. Feldman ($142,790 for 131 hours) and Daniel I. Forman (141,277.50 for 245 hours and 42 minutes).

The lawyers helped draft a bonus plan for RG Steel’s ten top managers to share up to $20 million in bonuses if the bankrupt steel company is successfully sold.

Other Willkie Farr lawyers feasting on RG Steel’s woes: Weston T. Eguchi ($100,667), David I. Gise ($96,876), Andrew S. Mordkoff ($83,960), Joshua M. Troy ($74,360) and Brian E. O’Connor ($51,121).

The New York lawyers were aided by the local co-counsel, Morris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnell LLP of Wilmington, which has not submitted its first month’s bill yet.

“Extraordinarily Large”

In recent years, as bankruptcy lawyers rocketed to the top of the fee ladder among corporate lawyers, there has been criticism of both the amount and the “opacity” of their professional charges.

The Executive Office of the U.S. Trustees, which administers the country’s bankruptcy courts, are proposing new rules for bankruptcy judges to use in approving lawyer’s fees.

In a speech last month, Cliff White, director of the trustees office, said, “The amount of professional fees incurred in the bankruptcy process is extraordinarily large by any measure. Public confidence in the bankruptcy system is sometimes shaken by reports of fees that run into the hundreds of millions of dollars in cases in which employees have lost their jobs, pension fund investors have largely been wiped out and creditors have been paid pennies on each dollar of debt.”

(White was referring to the $399 million in fees by the law firm handling the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy.)

In the RG Steel case, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Kevin J. Carey ruled that RG Steel will pay 80% of the submitted legal fees under an “interim compensation plan,” plus 100% of expenses.

It is unclear whether the law firms will be able to bill the company the remaining 20% at a later date.

Fair and Reasonable

Willkie Farr defended its fees as “fair and reasonable” given “the complexity of these cases; the time expended; the nature and extent of the services rendered; the value of such services; the skill and experience that WF&G has demonstrated in the bankruptcy field; and the costs of comparable services in cases other than cases under the Bankruptcy Code.”

The law firm said that it addressed many litigation matters, met with the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, identified executory contracts and unexpired leases for rejection as well as prepared cure schedules of executory contracts in connection for the planned sale of the company’s steelmaking mills in Maryland, Ohio and West Virginia.

The law firm also noted that filing this bill cost $79 in court fees and 0.1 hours in billable time. “WF&G intends to seek compensation in connection with preparation and filing of this Application at a later date,” it told Judge Carey.

Baltimore Brew is a moderated site that encourages the free and open exchange of ideas in a climate of mutual respect. We reserve the right - but do not assume any obligation - to delete or withhold the publication of comments that violate our standards. Comments that are obscene, libelous or defamatory, or include vicious personal attacks will not be published. Racist remarks, sexist remarks, disgusting stuff, blatant commercial self-promotion – you get the idea – if it crosses our line, we’re not going to run it.

  • Bigpapapump

    boy,their really rubbing our noses in it,id like to smack that smile off their faces

  • RAVENS 55

    NOW THIS IS JUST SOOO  NICE ISNT IT LMFAO JUST PRICELESS !!

  • Fordtrkfan

    I couldn’t even make it all the way through the article!  I am definitely applying to become a summer intern to make up some of the money that I have lost since being pretty much laid off!  They better hurry up and sell this place or they will only have enough money to pay the lawyers and the Exec bonuses! Wow, just one amazing story after another of great silliness going on with this whole deal. It is all criminal if you ask me! Mark Reutter, you should get recognized for your work on just the RG Steel stories alone! Keep up the great work! Now back to the article! 

  • My2Cents

    …And we got happy if we got a profit sharing check!!!

    There is no justice!    NONE ! ! !

    And they wonder why people go crazy!!!

  • My2Cents

    Everybody wins in this, well except for all those that actually did all of the HARD WORK!!!

    Charge all of these crooks into a vessel, either one, and let them swim in the orange hot metal. Let them get acclimated to the heat before they get thrusted int hell’s fire.

  • Fearme

    May God have mercey on their souls

  • My2Cents

    We (the steelworkers) are all victims. Where is our lawyers?? Our union representation?? Where is our government?? It’s an election year, somebody lie to me, at least tell me what I want to hear, even if you’re not gonna do it!! LIE TO ME!  Tell me that someone can stop this.

    These people are so wrong on so many levels.

    • msc#2operator

      dont worry 2 cents your international union is working hard to preserve your job and get u the best possible buyer and contract….any day now leo and dave will make their 1st statement on all this…..haven’t they always taken care of u in the past?  u wanted a lie, right?  truth is we are all screwed….and our government doesnt even care….

    • appalledinohio

      We’ve depended too long on lawyers, the union. and the GOV. This just proves what bullshit this entire matter is. No one cares about us middle-class working stiffs, they are all getting rich on our sorrows.

      It’s about time somebody in this country stands up to these elitest and why can’t it be us? Maybe the steelworkers can start the beginning of the end for these over- paid, prideless, financial leeches. I wonder how many of them could stand 8 hours in one of our mills?…….right? none of them.

      We should march on Washington(like the million man march) and have our grievances heard by the national media. Maybe then we could get someone to look into this criminal bullshit.

      What do you think, General Boothe???  Major, Guru???

      • wciheycraneman

        This type of crap has gone on too long and too far for a march to accomplish anything.  The people in this country have to wise up.  Unwrap their minds from their “hot button” issues they seem to only care about see the big picture.  The money people in this country manipulate the government, business and unfortunately the way to many people think.  Far too many of our citizens have become dupes for the rich.  How to reach them is the question.  If enough people finalize realize whats going on, then we would have the numbers to throw all those pious, sanctimonious liars who wrap themselves in the flag out like they did in 1932.  They shield themselves in the name of God and country but the whole time selling both out for the almighty dollar.  They don’t care about us, our country’s’ future or what America was originally based on when we revolted from England.  
        No appalled, we need more that a march.  We need a complete white-washing of our country.

        • appalledinohio

          Unfortunatly, you are probably right, Craneman. But we need to do something to shed a little light on this fiasco. During the “30′s” riots at stop 5 in Youngstown, my father went to jail for blowing up the railroad bridge between Republic Steel and the Sheet and Tube as the company was bringing scabs and food for them into Republic via that line, the only way in that was not covered by the workers.
          If only we had the balls to emulate the old timers……and after that bullshit, pop still went to Europe in “42′ to fight for this country and the robber-barons who inhabit it!!

      • Dr. Raymond Boothe

        General Boothe says-This is total BS of the highest order.The unions are supposed to have lawyers to protect steelworkers from this form of robbery. And yet, everything seems to participate in the robbery. First Ira and Goodbar’s gangsters rob the workers, and then the lawyers clean up the rest. What will be left?-Exactly Nothing. No jobs, no plants, no nothing. I agree that members should all march to the court and demand satisfaction. This is now out of control. No government official is looking out for the workers. I am afraid it is now time to act, in the past the USWA would never let this go by.

        I would love to see the breakdown of these charges. It is like a hospital bill. You have a right to see a line by line explanation of the charges. This is were your union dues are supposed to be working. Call them on it. Ask them why the National USW is not involved in this. It is the biggest steel legal action in the country. Where are they?

        Being experienced in lawsuits with steel mills in environmental suits, these lawyers spend money like water and hardly account for it. I have seen more waisted time in these type of suits and reorganizations. They charge way too much per hour for what they are worth and do not account for it. They just hand you one big ass bill for it and sue you if you do not pay the incredible amount.

        I am apalled beyond recognition, and you should be too. Every union hall needs to sponsor a bus and go to Deleware. There are just too many questions and outrageous acts going on that nobody seems to care about. 

        • newsflash

          cant afford a bus, need new cell phones, and some lighter fluid!

        • appalledinohio

          I’m telling you Doc, the only way to get to the bottom of this morass is for the brothers and sisters of steel to get RADICAL!!!!!!!
          Just like our national political problems, you can’t vote them out, you got to physically THROW them out.
          Just like 236 years ago, it’s time to throw the tea overboard and revolt against these political carpet baggers!!

    • diamond

      i can stop this, BUT I WONT!

  • Lex Apostata

    Why would any lawyer in his/her right mind take a job doing the clearly useless, valueless work of keeping criminals in jail, or helping poor people?

    • Alice

       It’s all about the money!

  • Claytoncook62

    this is bull$hit!!!!

  • H S

    The 1% taking care of the 1%, as usual. 

  • Walter

    When you look at the high cost of a Stacy London Wardrobe makeover, these billing rates are fair and reasonable. After the sale, Leo, Dave, and Mr. G, are taking everyone over to Stacy London’s place for a makeover too.

    The good news is that activity at SP is already starting. The pig boys are cleaning up and getting ready when the hot metal starts to flow again. They take a lot of hot metal after the Beast is down until she smooths out, no more beaching – just pigging until she is up to speed. These little signs are great news of the Point. We all are about ready for our Stacy London makeover, I cannot wait!

  • My2Cents

    Thats the thing… You can’t your point accross if demonstrations are done peacefully nowadays. They just ignore you. People in the early days of steelmaking didnt care about going to jail for acting out against an opressing government. They were poor and had nothing to lose a lot of times. We’re getting there fast. The HAVES VS. THE HAVE NOT’S.  

    Oh… and soon enough… the HAVES will be the only ones allowed to own guns!!

    God bless America!
      

  • Goody

    The haves do not need to own guns.They already own cops,judges, and politicians.

  • Baltimoreplaces

    No wonder why there are 10x’s the amount of lawyers than engineers and scientists.

  • Reality

    If you think the Law industry performs financial rape, then you really should check out the insurance, healthcare/pharmaceutical, and educational industries!

  • Rocco

    …….and some of these laid off Numb Nutz will still vote for Rmoney!

  • TACO

    Hey Walter, I heard that Stacy London is one of the top bidders, she is the only one left with the money to get the Point back up and running again. It does look like the primary side is getting positioned to fire back up as soon as they make the details of the deal public. Looks like they already worked out the terms of the contract and everyone is going to accept it or hit the road. Love it or leave it!  Let’s go over to career development center and sign up for law school and a makeover while O’Malley and Kevin are still footing the bill. At least the Point will be back up and running soon, it does not look so good for some of the western mills. Good luck guys.

  • Lawyers, Bankers and CEO’s

    Good job Mark!!!! ….And people wonder why this country is in trouble. Bastards all of them. The laws in this country have to change.  When is the working man going to be protected???

    • Walter

      When is Sparrows Point going to be given the tax breaks, grant money, and relief from governmental red tape to make a dollar.   And yes, Mark is doing a great job and we will see him at the big party the new owners are having in front of the Main Office.

    • WPSC

       The no good, bottom feeders that sustain their existence off of the backs of the working man are the same ones responsible for enacting the laws that enable them to pilfer us blind ! 70 to 80 % of the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government are bought and paid for. The working man will be protected again after the revolution and when the sheeple awaken from their  AIPAC induced hibernation they have been lulled into over the last fifty years by the mainstream media.Face it, we have been indoctrinated since kindergarten to never think critically and to do as we are told. The United States has progressed from a nanny nation to a dictatorship !

  • Walter

    And Barbie has done a wonderful job in quickly getting the housing and new medical center built for our Veterans at the old fort Howard Hospital.
    A beautiful complex with a lovely view of the RG slag pile.  Dream on LawyerBankerCEO boy!  

    • Nashorn

      Unfortunately Walter, many vets I know are much more concerned with what’s inside those new buildings, which is the same old (not very good) quality of care. Few think that the VA healthcare system is a particularly attractive model for the civilian population 

  • Guest

    Has anyone ever watched the movie ” They Live”.  Sort of makes you wonder.

  • msc#2operator

    if u think the company’s lawyers bills are high, wait til u see the international’s lawyers fees……the law firm of yockesteen and mitchellini out of new york is even higher….

    • yiayia

      your union is making more than this!

  • Unellu

    Shaunna Jones looks like she stepped off the cover of Vogue.  Lawyers write the arcane rules that must be obeyed, then charge a ton to make sure the rules are indeed obeyed .  They make their own bed of roses and lie in it.  What a bunch of crooks. 

  • WPSC

    One other note of mention. Other than Mark Reutter, Paul Craig Roberts, and the infamous Ben Swann from Channel 19 out of Cincinnati, I am aware of no other journalists that still have enough integrity to actually do investigative journalism ! Fact. CNN ( Cartoon News Network), Faux News, MSNBC, all staffed to the hilt with AIPAC shills and automatons that are never, ever permitted to deviate from what their teleprompters command them to disseminate to the hibernating masses of America ! Given this, to Mark and Ben, you have the admiration and respect of the people that are still able to exhibit critical thinking skills! March on proudly as the revolution awaits you ! Oh, and God Bless the Internet, as it is the last bastion of free speech we still have access to !

    This is a very adept freedom fighter that knows the score from the inside out !   http://www.paulcraigroberts.org/

  • Steve

    Nice piece of reporting but nothing nothing really new. This stuff has been going on since there were attorneys. Problem is that most legislators that could possibly change things are also attorneys. You can expect even more of this if Republicans get control of the presidency the house and senate. We live in a capitalist society that rewards greed. We need to go into rehab.

  • no more time

         lawers get payed ceos get payed try to move your vacation now there is justice

  • No211

    That is nothing,  you should see what the trustee and firm of Jaburg & Wilk of Phoenix, AZ has and continues to bill in the American National Mortgage Partners/Castle Boutique deals,  they dwarf these guys hands down, on companies that are a fraction of the size of RG,  take a look,  you decide what is criminal. 

    • BigPicture

      Let’s look at the big picture, RG management picks the “stalking horse” , same people given 20 million in bribes, let’s see who out of current management ends up with positions (or ownership) with the new owners.  Lawyers fees?  Big deal, corporate bankruptcies have taken advantage of these situations for the last twenty years. It has been accepted as a cost of doing business. In perspective, SP lost that much in a couple days.

  • Union my toosh

    You people that are staying are just enabling RG to screw you more, you just keep making your paultry money and let them screw you more and more everyday, while they clean up.

  • msc#1operator

    why does the company always have us by the balls?   i asked this question to a 30 year   local union official the other day…..her response kinda shocked me when she said be prepared for major cuts in a new contract if a new company takes over…y cant we ever stand up to these companies? If u want to buy us why do i need to give u concessions? when i told the union official to tell the company to shove any concessions up their ass she seemed puzzled….dont give up jobs and concessions without a fight…call their bluff for once and let’s get the upper hand back….im sick of this losing mentality the union has…if your gonna give up everything our grandfathers fought for, then id rather u just shut it down….

    • 1190memberforjustice

      i have been saying that for years, the union reps dont give a dam because they will lose nothing no union rep ever did, they will tell you different but they dont. these people, all they do is leach off the good union people. why do we need all those people sitting at the union hall they do nothing! worthless! the word concessions started at 1190.

      • Bry465

        there all sitting there waiting for mccall to appear so they can give there master a good lapping. i bet when he leaves he will have the cleanest cheeks in town.

    • yiayia

      well its like this! you voted for the clowns.

  • 1190isdone

    does this mean its over for the more than 1000 union workers at mingo?

  • Mickey 111

    told  ya….sp  is  scray…all  new  buniness…maybe  5  yrs  from  now   5000   people  working  there…

  • May 23, 2013

  • May 22, 2013

    • As city firefighters face the possibility of 24-hour-long shifts to save money, Fire Chief James Clack today announced the filling of two newly-created administrative positions, each carrying annual salaries of about $100,000. In addition, Clack named Ian T. Brennan, Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake’s assistant press secretary, as the department’s public information officer, replacing the retiring Kevin [...]

  • May 21, 2013

    • The Board of Estimates will be asked tomorrow to make Associated Catholic Charities the new operator of the city’s homeless shelter, replacing longtime provider JHR (Jobs, Housing and Recovery), Inc. The Mayor’s Office of Human Services is asking the board to approve a one-year $2.7 million contract for ACC to run the 250-plus-bed shelter, beginning [...]

  • May 17, 2013

    • UPDATED – At his stop at a South Baltimore factory this afternoon, President Obama announced a plan to boost the economy by reducing the red tape required on large federal projects. “Sometimes it takes too long to get projects off the ground,” Obama said at Ellicott Dredges, citing permits and planning delays related to infrastructure [...]

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • December 10, 2012

    • We Brew-ers have been gradually getting our act together to finally give our Kickstarter contributors their Thank You mugs, bumper stickers and other rewards. On Saturday we knocked out one more of those formal thank yous in a borrowed conference room downtown. It was a “Baltimore Brew Staff Meeting.” We mostly have lower-case “staff meetings,” [...]

Twitter

Facebook