Taxpayers give the mayor an earful about the 2013 budget

At Taxpayers' Night, the budget process itself gets blasted

taxpayer kt 2

“You’ve offended our children,” citizen activist Kim Trueheart told Mayor Rawlings-Blake.

Photo by: Fern Shen

One of Baltimore’s most passionate and best prepared citizen activists led the way Wednesday at the annual Taxpayers’ Night, lambasting Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake and other members of the Board of Estimates over a proposed 2013 city budget she said shortchanges children and neighborhoods.

“This is a foul budget,” said activist Kim Trueheart. “You’ve offended us. You’ve offended our children.”

Sitting silently before an audience of about 50 people (nearly half of them city officials and media), the board’s members, including Rawlings-Blake and City Council President Bernard C. “Jack” Young, let the sometimes scorching comments of a half-dozen speakers go unanswered.

Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake listened to speakers criticize the 2013 Baltimore city budget. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake listens to speakers criticize the 2013 budget that her office crafted. (Photo by Fern Shen)

That’s the usual scenario for this yearly ritual, required by the city charter as part of the budget process, which continues through June 25th, when the City Council is required to pass a balanced budget.

Held at the War Memorial Building across from City Hall, Taxpayer Night typically features pleas on behalf of axed or shrunken budget items and critiques of misplaced priorities.

This year Trueheart supplied plenty of both.

“You Aren’t Even Close”

“This disinvestment in our rec centers has to stop, okay!?” Trueheart said, referring to the mayor’s controversial plan to close as many as eight city recreation centers and give others to private groups or, in the latest effort, to Baltimore City Public Schools.

The rec center consolidation, along with announced plans to close seven small public pools this summer, are among the belt-tightening measures implicit in the $2.3 billion operating budget Rawlings-Blake is proposing amid a $48 million deficit.

 Cutbacks have left the parks advisory board "frustrated," Carolyn Wainwright said. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Cutbacks have left the parks advisory board "frustrated," Carolyn Wainwright said. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Trueheart also decried the mayor’s plan to cut 30 after-school programs.

She noted that at an election forum last summer, the mayor promised to double funding for after-school programs and to support recreation centers and other youth and neighborhood programs.

“You aren’t even close to what you promised,”  she said, as Rawlings-Blake looked down and occasionally glanced at the microphone where Trueheart stood facing her fiercely.

Another speaker, Leon Bailey, pleaded with Rawlings-Blake to “please don’t cut rec centers.”

“I became a responsible person at the McKim Community Center,” Bailey said. “It played an important part in my life.”

Carolyn Wainwright, a member of the Recreation and Parks Department advisory board, said she and other board members are “frustrated” by the imminent closure of pools and rec centers.

She called for the city to do an audit of the department and get new leadership. (Last month, Gregory Bayer announced his resignation as agency director after less than two years at the post.)

Fiery Speech and Fire Station Warning

Neighborhoods, one speaker said, will be the victim of another part of the budget – the plan to permanently close three fire companies. Earlier this month, the city fire chief identified two ladder truck and one engine company he plans to shut down.

“The closures will compromise safety across the city,” said John Burke, secretary treasurer of IAFF Local 734. Baltimore’s population decline doesn’t mean fewer firefighters are needed, Burke said before the meeting.

Firefighter John Burke spoke out against the closure of fire stations. (Photo by Fern Shen

Firefighter John Burke spoke out against the closure of fire stations. (Photo by Fern Shen)

“The square miles never change, we still have 96 square miles to cover,” Burke said. “People don’t burn – buildings do.”

One of the evening’s most fiery speakers was not there in person. Hathaway Ferebee, executive director of the Safe and Sound Campaign, sent in written testimony, which was read by Young.

“We fear that the budget ratifies the status quo, deepening structural racism and fostering crime as a direct result of a failing city,” Ferebee wrote.

Ferebee asked the board to “please include the list of outcomes you expect from your decisions.”

“How many more babies will be born healthy, how far will infant mortality decline, what will be the increase in children entering school ready to learn; how many fewer incidences of disruption at the harbor place; how many graduating seniors will have bank accounts and a positive credit score,” she asked.

More withering remarks came from Tom Kiefaber, former owner of the Senator Theatre, who spent his time at the microphone blasting the quasi-public Baltimore Development Corporation (BDC) for its “backroom deals.”

The agency should be independently audited, Kiefaber told the board, if not “disbanded or revamped so it doesn’t allow for this type of shadow government.”

Deficits and Doomsday

In her remarks welcoming citizens to the event, Rawlings-Blake talked about the challenge of balancing the city’s books.

She stressed not only the deficit but the extra squeeze the city would feel if the state were to enact the so-called “doomsday budget” produced in the waning days of an especially discordant legislative session in Annapolis.

“Unless the state acts to reverse the cuts, an additional $20.2 million in cuts will be added to the city’s preliminary budget, along with approximately $22 million in cuts to the Baltimore City Public School System’s budget,” Rawlings-Blake said, reading prepared remarks.

“The potential city cuts resulting from the state budget include canceling academy classes to hire new police officers and/or layoffs, cutting violent crime and gun prosecutors, and reinstating the furlough program for city employees, which was scheduled to be phased-out this year,” the mayor continued.

Transparent? Or Obscure?

Many speakers critiqued the budget process itself, saying the Taxpayers Night event was poorly advertised and that information about the spending plan is not easy to find online.

“I am very interested in the budget – I organized 40 people to come to a budget exercise in February – but I didn’t learn about this until a couple of days ago,” said Mike McGuire, an activist involved in the Occupy Baltimore action.

“I was combing through the website to find it out,” he said, speaking to city budget director Andrew Kleine before the event began. “Did you advertise the date?”

Activists Casey McKeel and Mike McGuire at Baltimore Taxpayer Night 2012. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Activists Casey McKeel and Mike McGuire at Baltimore Taxpayers' Night. To their right: Tom Kiefaber. (Photo by Fern Shen)

Kleine said the city followed the advertisement requirements specified in the city charter, including an ad in the Baltimore Sun in January.

Council President Young, who sits as the president of the Board of Estimates, apparently overheard their conversation.

“A lot of people seem to think we wasn’t advertising this,” Young said to the audience. “We tried to be as transparent as possible.”

“I disagree,” Trueheart said, when her turn came to speak. She said city officials have shown  “no real interest” in engaging the public. “What’s wrong with email? What’s wrong with Facebook?” she asked.

Trueheart also asked officials why there was no copy of the proposed capital budget online, “just a  summary.” (Pressed on this point before the meeting began, Kleine had told Trueheart, “If it’s not there it should be,” and promised to check on the matter.)

After two people (McGuire and activist Casey McKeel) yielded their allotted two-minute speaking time to her, Trueheart was able to return several times to the microphone to make more remarks.

Advocating more budget support for neighborhoods, children and fiscal oversight (“the Legislative Reference budget is decreasing by 5%?”), she recommended less for police (“get rid of that inflated police budget”) and the BDC (“nobody’s building nothing!”).

As the meeting broke up, participants asked Young when the City Council would hold its version of Taxpayers Night. He promised that the date would be announced at the April 30th Council meeting.

McGuire urged Young to use social networks to spread the word about subsequent budget events more effectively.

“I ‘like’ you on Facebook. I ‘like’ the mayor,” he said. “But I didn’t hear anything about this.”

Be sure to check our full comment policy before leaving a comment.

  • Daniel E

    Best way to get SRB to side with you – be a big business and howl about taxes or donate to her upcoming election.

  • parkside

    There has been multiple fires where the closest fire company was CLOSED temporarily to save money, now the city wants to close two of the busiest companies permanently. The FD lies and says it doesn’t matter if the company is closed. The members of your firehouses want to do everything they can for the citizens in thier districts. Not only do they respond to fires, they handle medical emergencies, water leaks, gas leaks, CO leaks, buildings in dangerous conditions, housing issues, and smoke detectors to name a few.  when citizens call they want a response from the city and the FD always arrive right away. No other city department can say that. We were voted by the citizens to have the highest approval rating for any department. Now the city wants to cut the one department that the citizens are happy with. Think of how high the murder rate would be without the dedicated members of the FD. These are your taxes used wisely! Can the city show you where they spend taxes and get quality like this?                                                                                                      

  • Ktrueheart

    I thank Ms.  Carolyn Wainwright, a member of the Recreation and Parks Department advisory board and her fellow members for lobbying our legislators in Annapolis for over $1M of Open Space funding to keep City pools open this summer … Good Work!

  • Westside Resident

    I think we need to hire some more consultants.

  • JS

    My heart goes out to Leon Bailey.  Not only is SRB wanting to cut funding to rec centers, the McKim Community Center building–a beautiful 1833 historic replica of a Greek temple–is one of the landmarks the City may sell. It was used for over 100 years as a free school for indigent youth, and its use as a rec center for young people continued this mission.  It’s true the building is in desperate need of repair, but isn’t there some way to find the funds to honor the history of this building and the residents of Jonestown who need a rec center?

  • Unellu

    Between the Brew and the citizens who want answers it is becoming a close shave for the rulers–and YET–they manage to be obdurate, corrupt, obfuscatory and absolutely set in their ways.  Remarkable tenacity of wrong headed purpose is all I can say.  KTrueheart is a sterling activist–she defines the meaning of a true democracy.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • December 15, 2014

    •   “Ha ha, so not a surprise.” “Shocking…not!!” We get applause but also the occasional eye-roll these days for our accountability reporting – like last week’s piece about how tax cuts promised by the mayor as a selling point for Horseshoe Baltimore probably won’t happen, thanks to the casino’s lower-than-expected revenues. We get where the […]