Monroe Street bike lane: Gone baby gone

Now that was quick. City removes the controversial West Baltimore bike lane over the weekend.

1Arthur McDowell

Arthur McDowell stands today on Monroe Street next to the removed bike lane.

Photo by: Mark Reutter

A day after the city canceled a meeting that bike advocates hoped would save a bike lane in West Baltimore, the lane was rubbed out and the old vehicular traffic pattern restored.

Paving crews were out in force on Saturday scraping off the white stripes and sharrows installed on Monroe Street five months ago – quick work aimed at appeasing a community association whose president was at pains today to say he’s not anti-bike.

“If the point was to establish as many bike lanes for the safety and health of the community as possible, then I would hope it doesn’t end with us simply taking out the lane on Monroe,” said Franklin Lance, president of the Greater Mondawmin Coordinating Council.

“I’m asking bike enthusiasts and avid readers of your site: ‘What are the attributes of a good bike lane so we can come up with three or four possibilities and say, ‘DOT [Department of Transportation] put a bike lane here?’”

Lance has emailed biking activists, as well as community members and city officials, to try and rally a continuing dialogue.

Let’s Talk About New Lanes

He even thought of some places – Pulaski Street, Warwick Avenue and a part of Wabash Avenue. “I don’t want it to be Greater Mondawmin against the bicyclists.”

But Penny Troutner, interim chair of the Mayor’s Bicycle Advisory Committee, seemed less than enthusiastic about debating future bike lanes when the city canceled a meeting Friday in which cyclists and community leaders were to sit down and hash out the fate of the existing lane.

The freshly minted Monroe St. bike lane back in June. (Marla Streb,

The freshly minted Monroe bike lane back in June. (Marla Streb,

“I’m disappointed in Dr. Lance for not taking the meeting on Friday,” she said. (Lance confirmed that he declined to attend the meeting because keeping the Monroe lane open was not an option, he said, when DOT had already pledged to the community to remove it.)

Asked why the bike lane was removed Saturday, just days after The Brew wrote that some local residents supported the lane and others felt the city could make it more useful, DOT spokeswoman Adrienne Barnes said today, “We told you – there were some safety issues. And a decision was made to do these things differently. We need to talk to the community folks first [before installing a lane].”

Accidents Under the Old Traffic Pattern

Marsha Franklin scoffed at the argument that the bike lane was causing safety problems. The longtime Monroe Street resident said today, “We had a lot of accidents before they put in the lane. Just this year, three children on bicycles got hit by cars. And one adult. A couple of these were hit-and-runs.”

Franklin said these accidents were not hearsay. “I saw them. I sit on the stoop and read my book. It was safer having the bike lane. Taking it away isn’t right.”

Another resident, Arthur McDowell, said that restoring both traffic lanes for cars will cause traffic to flow more smoothly.

“This is a main thoroughfare. I’m not at all sure a bike lane was right for Monroe Street. But I am sure the city never did handle this right. First they put it in without anyone knowing about it. Then they took it out without anyone knowing about it.”

Two traffic lanes restored on the 1900 block of Monroe St. (Photo by Mark Reutter)

Two traffic lanes restored on the 1900 block of Monroe St. (Photo by Mark Reutter)

Conaway Says Advocates Didn’t Reach Out

Councilwoman Belinda K. Conaway, whose opposition to the bike lane was considered instrumental in getting DOT to remove it, today praised Dr. Lance for vowing to discuss other places where a bicycle lane would be more appropriate.

She criticized bike advocates for not reaching out to the community earlier. “Instead of taking the time to reach out to the community, they never got back to them,” Conaway said. “That was their error, not reaching out to the affected community. They were pretty late in the game reaching out to us.”

Troutner said she had been in touch with members of the Greater Mondawmin Coordinating Council and did what she could to alert them to her position that the bike lane would help save cyclists’ lives.

“I would have liked to have seen the city take a leadership role and bring us together,” Troutner continued. “They could have required a meeting before that lane was lifted. Now it’s gone, and cyclists are back out on the road with no protection.”

– Fern Shen also contributed to this story.

Be sure to check our full comment policy before leaving a comment.

  • Walter

    Oh thank you Ms. Conaway!  Now you need to fire the knucklehead who painted “Bike Lane” on such a narrow and busy thoroughfare.

    Makes as much sense as painting “Bike Lane” down the middle of the Jones Falls Expressway!

    Now I can drive my Buick down Monroe Street without worrying about having a cyclist comment suicide by old Walter’s Buick Electra!


    • Dukiebiddle

      It isn’t narrow and it isn’t busy.

    • Penny Troutner

      It indeed is not narrow or busy.  Perhaps Walter was being sarcastic in comparing Monroe St. to an expressway?  I know the neighbors would like the traffic calmed, and that’s what bike lanes do.  They also give bicyclists some small degree of protection against 2,000 lb vehicles, and that’s a good thing.   People driving on Monroe St. as though it were the JFX, that’s a bad thing.

  • Jed Weeks

    Councilwoman Conaway never responded to my multiple attempts to contact her on this issue. How is that my error?

  • Curtis

    Put the pedal to the metal and let the good times roll. . . because you have 24 foot lateral clearance, 2 lanes to choose from, and stretches where there’s no car in front of you.  All in the name of safety.   

    There’s no money to do it here in Bmore, but 15th Street in Northwest DC is a great example of separating bike lanes from traffic by having the bike ride between parked cars and the sidewalks.  Only difference there is that that street actually can fill-up with cars. 

  • VinceVance

    I also sent Ms. Conaway a message about my support of the bike lane. Never got a response. In my book “they were ignored” is not the same as “they never reached out”.

  • ibbieta

    Wasn’t this route in the Bike Master Plan?

  • cleancut77

    Good pesky bikers need to move off the road.

  • November 24, 2015

  • November 23, 2015

    • Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake will be off to Paris late next week, leading a delegation of the U.S. Conference of Mayors, of which she is president, to participate in the United Nations convention on climate change. According to information released this afternoon in the Board of Estimates agenda, the mayor will be in Paris from December […]

  • November 20, 2015

    • The Roland Park Place retirement community took a step closer to starting a major renovation and expansion yesterday when the Planning Commission gave “final design approval” to the first phase of the project. Plans by Hord Coplan Macht call for the first phase to include improvements to the existing building and grounds at 830 West […]

  • November 19, 2015

  • November 18, 2015

    • The Board of Estimates temporarily put the brakes on a plan to build a new courtroom and judge’s chambers in the Clarence M. Mitchell Jr. Courthouse after City Council President Bernard C. “Jack” Young questioned the amount of money it would cost. The spending panel was asked today to approve a request to transfer $1.2 […]

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • December 15, 2014

    •   “Ha ha, so not a surprise.” “Shocking…not!!” We get applause but also the occasional eye-roll these days for our accountability reporting – like last week’s piece about how tax cuts promised by the mayor as a selling point for Horseshoe Baltimore probably won’t happen, thanks to the casino’s lower-than-expected revenues. We get where the […]