Pratt lawsuit against mayor thrown out by judge

Judge calls Pratt's complaint about VOIP phone bid "serious" but not "legally cognizable."

A Circuit Court judge tonight dismissed a lawsuit filed by City Comptroller Joan Pratt over Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake’s plan to work with Digicon Corp. to install an Internet-based phone system for city employees.

“The stuff alleged in [the complaint] doesn’t give me any comfort that there is an actionable complaint,” Judge Pamela J. White said Wednesday evening after three hours of arguments, according to the Maryland Daily Record.

While calling the comptroller’s allegations that the city circumvented the competitive bidding process in contracting with Digicon “serious,” the judge said Pratt’s complaint is not “legally cognizable in this place at this time.”

“I have tried mightily to find something that should raise a problem and I cannot,” White said. “I must deal with the reality of actionable legal claims, and I can’t find it here.”

White also said she didn’t believe the comptroller “has any business suing the mayor and the City Council.”

The judge dismissed the suit with prejudice, meaning that Pratt cannot amend or refile the complaint.

City Solicitor George Nilson said he was pleased with Judge White’s decision. He had argued that under the city’s charter, a city employee cannot employ outside counsel unless the solicitor certifies that there is an irreconcilable conflict and the Board of Estimates concurs.

Pratt filed her private lawsuit in October claiming the administration circumvented the city’s bidding process in contracting with Rockville-based Digicon to install a Voice Over Internet Protocol (VOIP) phone system, and sued to prevent the city from proceeding with the contract.

The comptroller, whose office has jurisdiction over the municipal phone system, has repeatedly urged the Board of Estimates to approve a contract with IBM.

But the five-member board – controlled by Mayor Rawlings-Blake – rejected the IBM bid last July.

Be sure to check our full comment policy before leaving a comment.

  • discer

    A  approropiate response to a frivilous action.

  • Barnadine_the_Pirate

    Growing bored with disgracing herself through her inaction, Pratt branches out into disgracing herself with her actions.

  • Barnadine_the_Pirate

    There are rules. They just aren’t the rules that appear in writing anywhere.

  • ushanellore

    A blow to the Comptroller’s ego–in the end this is what the suit was about–her bruised ego.  In this litigious society a whole lot of suits are about bruised egos.  The comptroller thought dirty linen dragged through the city courts would teach the mayor who’s boss.  Instead she got lemon squeezed on her face.  Another victory for SRB–that woman lives a charmed life.

More of the Daily Drip »

Below the Fold

  • December 15, 2014

    •   “Ha ha, so not a surprise.” “Shocking…not!!” We get applause but also the occasional eye-roll these days for our accountability reporting – like last week’s piece about how tax cuts promised by the mayor as a selling point for Horseshoe Baltimore probably won’t happen, thanks to the casino’s lower-than-expected revenues. We get where the […]